What’s the difference?
PLA and TPU are the two common materials for 3D printing. However, the two materials behave differently, have different properties, and have several advantages and disadvantages.
Here are the differences between PLA and TPU:
Ease of printing
PLA is one of the easiest 3D printing materials you can use. It is an ideal choice for beginners and is available in various colors and blends. Oppositely, TPU is a bit hard to use. It is challenging to post-process and likely to clog.
Clogging and jamming
PLA is more environmentally friendly and compostable than TPU. Thus, it is easier to print and a good choice for beginners. On the other hand, TPU is more prone to clogging and stringing than PLA.
Smell and health issues while printing
PLA is made from sugarcane and cornstarch. Thus, it gives out a sweet aroma when printing. In addition, it is the least harmful 3D printing material to human health. On the other hand, TPU emits an odor when printing. Even though the odor is not hostile, it is not as sweet as the PLA aroma. Also, the fumes are not so strong for someone to leave the printing room. The use of TPU can cause a harmful allergy. The toxic substances released when printing can cause health problems such as eye irritation, difficulty breathing, or even organ damage.
Hygroscope and post-processing
One shortcoming of PLA is that it is highly hygroscopic. It means it can easily absorb moisture from the environment. Based on the humidity, the material can be rendered unusable. Nevertheless, it is easier to post-process a PLA material. Also, TPU is hygroscopic. It is a material that can easily absorb moisture when exposed. You are therefore advised to keep the material in a dry box. Moreover, it is a challenge to post-process a TPU material. Performing any task on printed art is not easy.
Flexibility
When you compare PLA and TPU, PLA cannot make flexible designs. So, if you are looking for a material to design flexible designs, the best one to consider is TPU. However, since TPU is so flexible, it isn’t easy to print. It is elastic and flexible, making it unpopular to beginners.
Durability and strength
LA is user-friendly and among the easiest materials for 3D printing. However, it has poor durability and strength compared to TPU. On the other hand, TPU is a bridge between plastic and rubber. The material is flexible, rubber-like, and smooth. In addition, it is solid and durable.
Temperature requirements
PLA is a versatile material that prints best at 210 °C. However, it can work well from 180 °C to 230 °C. PLA does not need a heated bed. Nevertheless, if the printer has one, you can set it at 20 °C to 60 °C. With TPU, it works best from 220 °C to 250 °C. Also, the material does not require a bed. But if your printer has a bed, the temperature should not be higher than 60 °C.
Cracking, warping, heated bed, and adhesion
When using PLA, you may have issues with cracking. This is because the material can absorb moisture causing it to reduce flexibility. Also, warping can happen due to PLA shrinkage while printing. PLA is a printing material that does not require a heated bed. But for the layers to be successfully printed, the first layer has to stick to the printer surface, also known as bed adhesion. TPU does not have a significant cracking issue like PLA. Also, there are no warping issues experienced when using PLA and other 3D printing materials. For quality 3D printing, heat beds are needed. However, TPU does not require a heated bed to print. Also, TPU is resistant to low temperatures. Moreover, it has interlayer adhesion.